Kevin Martin · The Federal Budget

An Audit Is Not an Accusation. It Is How You Find Out Whether the Money Did What You Said It Would.

Kevin Martin on why auditing federal programs is a routine management function, not a partisan weapon, and what should happen when a program cannot show its results.

People hear the word audit and assume somebody is in trouble.

In my line of work, it means almost the opposite. An audit is routine. It is the thing you do every year so that everyone can rely on the numbers. Most audits find nothing dramatic. They find a process that drifted, a control that stopped being applied, a number that was right three years ago and nobody re-checked. Audits help us discover when there is potentially a point of disconnect in process that leads to loss of assets. They identify these shortcomings that need to be repaired, corrected, or terminated altogether, so that we can be effective, efficient, protective, and productive whether it's a business (public or private), government, or personal.

That is the spirit I mean when I say Congress should audit everything.

What auditing a program actually means

Not an investigation. Four questions, asked on a schedule:

What was this program supposed to accomplish? What did it cost? What did it actually accomplish? And is the difference between the second and third numbers worth it?

Most federal programs cannot answer question three. Not because anyone hid it. Because nobody was ever required to produce it, so nobody built the system to collect it. A program gets created, gets funded, and then gets re-funded every year on the assumption that it is still doing what it was created to do. Nobody checks. There is no line in the process where checking happens.

If a company ran that way, the auditors would qualify the opinion and the bank would call.

The example that proves the point

The Department of Defense has failed its financial audit eight years running. Every audit since Congress required them starting in 2018. It is the only one of the government's twenty-four major agencies that has never passed. The most recent one identified twenty-six material weaknesses.

I want to be fair about what that does and does not mean, because it gets exaggerated in both directions. It does not mean money was stolen. A failed audit means the auditors could not get enough reliable information to form an opinion on the financial statements.

Think about what that sentence means for the largest organization on earth. Not that the money went somewhere bad. That we cannot say with confidence where it went.

The department says it aims to pass by 2028. I hope it does. But I would point out that eight years of failing and a promise about year eleven is the kind of timeline that would not survive a board meeting anywhere else.

What Congress actually controls

Congress required the Pentagon audit in the first place, which is worth remembering. When Congress decides something must be measured, it gets measured.

Congress can attach reporting requirements to any appropriation. It can require outcome data as a condition of renewal. It funds GAO and the inspectors general, who already produce far more findings than Congress acts on. It can sunset programs so they must justify renewal rather than continue by default.

All available. Rarely used.

Over the last two budgets, FY 2024 and 2025, improper payments accounted for $162 Billion and $186 Billion, with a majority being overpayments. This does not include high-risk programs such as Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. And, since 2003, improper payments have reached nearly $3 TRILLION. (US Government Accountability Office).

The two key points of issues are with Compliance Gaps and Noncompliance Patterns, where under the Payment Integrity Information Act (PIIA) of 2019, 12 of the 24 reporting agencies did NOT comply with PIIA criteria in FY 2024. And seven agencies had programs with more than 10% improper payment rates for 2-4 consecutive years. The DOL and Treasury either failed to submit timely reports or any at all. (US Government Accountability Office).

Where are the documented policies/procedures to ensure timely compliance? Congress? And the funny, Ha, I forgot to laugh moment... The OMB guidance does not explicitly require noncompliant agencies to submit annual reports. (US Government Accountability Office). If we don't hold Congress and Government Agencies accountable for our tax dollars being spent, how can we hold non-tax paying citizens accountable for not paying taxes?

What needs to change

Every program reports outcomes, on a schedule, in public. Not activity. Outcomes. How many people, what changed for them, at what cost per person.

Sunset dates on new programs. If it works, renewing is easy. If nobody can show it works, it should have to end rather than continue because ending requires a vote nobody wants to take.

Act on the findings that already exist. GAO and the inspectors general publish recommendations constantly. A large share goes unimplemented for years. We do not have an information problem. We have a follow-through problem.

Fund the auditors properly. Oversight is one of the few places where spending reliably returns more than it costs, and it is chronically underfunded because it has no constituency.

Why I care about this more than most people

Because I have done it. I have been the person who has to say the number is wrong and watch a room get uncomfortable. Business had died by simply not setting rules, writing policies, and setting procedures in place to monitor and evaluate production, costs, and revenues. A simple mind set learned in Management Theory at Georgia Tech - Plan, Organize, and Control. POC. Thank you, Dr. Adler.

It is not fun and nobody thanks you. What I learned is that most waste is not theft. It is drift. People simply do not have guidance, policy, and procedures in place. It is a program that made sense in 1994, and nobody has looked at since, running on autopilot with a budget line and no owner.

You do not find that with outrage. You find it by looking, on a schedule, at everything and asking that question our 5-year-old children ask - WHY.

Sources

It's your turn to be important.

It only takes a minute to tell Kevin what you need him to focus on.

No spam, ever.